---

Order and History by Eric Voegelin

Eric Voegelin’s Order and History is a monumental, five-volume work that examines the philosophical and historical origins of modern gnosticism and its impact on Western political thought. The work isn’t a linear history in the traditional sense, but rather a comparative study of cosmological and eschatological beliefs across various cultures, from ancient Egypt and Israel to Greece, Rome, and Renaissance Europe. Voegelin argues that modern ideologies, particularly those arising from the French Revolution, represent a secularized form of gnosticism – a belief in esoteric knowledge that promises salvation through the transformation of the world.

What the Book Explores

At its core, Order and History explores the relationship between humanity’s search for meaning, the symbolic expressions of that search in mythology and religion, and the emergence of modern political ideologies. Voegelin identifies a pattern in human history where societies develop “immanentized eschatologies” – attempts to bring about a perfect world within the confines of history, often through revolutionary means. He analyzes the philosophical foundations of these ideologies, tracing them back to ancient dualistic beliefs that separate the world into good and evil, spirit and matter. Voegelin emphasizes the importance of understanding these underlying spiritual and metaphysical assumptions to comprehend the nature of modern political phenomena. The work investigates the concept of ‘the in-between’, the human existence situated between the divine and the earthly, and how disruptions to this order contribute to societal upheaval.

Historical / Cultural Context

Voegelin began writing Order and History in the aftermath of World War II, deeply concerned by the totalitarian ideologies that had fueled the conflict. The book was a direct response to what he perceived as a crisis of Western civilization, stemming from the loss of traditional values and the rise of secular utopianism. The work represents a conservative intellectual counter-offensive to the dominant historical narratives of the mid-20th century, which often emphasized material factors and social progress. Voegelin’s background in political science and his deep engagement with classical philosophy, theology, and history shaped his distinctive approach. He drew heavily on the work of thinkers like Plato, Aristotle, Augustine, and Thomas Aquinas, as well as ancient Near Eastern and Egyptian sources. The book’s publication across the 1950s was significant within Cold War intellectual circles, offering a profound critique of both communism and modern liberalism.

Who This Book Is For

This work is primarily aimed at readers with a serious interest in political philosophy, intellectual history, and comparative religion. Its complexity and length demand a level of scholarly commitment. While it’s not light reading, those interested in understanding the roots of modern ideologies and the enduring human quest for meaning will find it deeply rewarding. Readers familiar with classical and medieval philosophy will be particularly well-equipped to engage with Voegelin’s arguments. The book is often studied in university courses on political thought and the history of ideas.

Further Reading

• The Politics of the Immaculate Conception by Eric Voegelin
• Science, Politics and Gnosticism by Eric Voegelin
• The Myth of the State by Ernst Jünger
• The Crisis of Modern Science by René Guénon

---